Does Vascular Elasticity Affect Arteriovenous Fistula Maturation?
William D. Paulson*
Identifiers and Pagination:Year: 2014
Issue: Suppl 1: M4
First Page: 26
Last Page: 32
Publisher ID: TOUNJ-7-26
Article History:Received Date: 3/10/2013
Revision Received Date: 1/4/2014
Acceptance Date: 4/4/2014
Electronic publication date: 30/5/2014
Collection year: 2014
open-access license: This is an open access article licensed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/3.0/) which permits unrestricted, non-commercial use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the work is properly cited.
The vasculopathy of ESRD affects both arteries and veins. The arteries develop arteriosclerosis, which is largely a disease of the media characterized by increased collagen content, calcification, and both hypertrophy and hyperplasia of vascular smooth muscle cells. Veins may exhibit increased width of the intimal and medial layers, and may develop neointimal hyperplasia and calcification. Successful fistula maturation depends upon dilatation and remodeling of the artery and vein, but the stiff and thickened vessels of ESRD patients may respond poorly to signals that promote these adaptations. There is intense interest in accurately predicting fistula maturation outcome and preventing maturation failure. However, definitive criteria for preoperative testing of vessel elasticity have not yet been established. Tests that are adopted for widespread clinical use will need to be easy to apply - a standard that many of these tests may not meet. Finally, effective treatments are needed that prevent or reduce the stiffness of vessels. In conclusion, although there are many promising developments in this emerging field, effective methods of predicting fistula maturation outcome and preventing maturation failure remain to be established.
Failure of native arteriovenous fistulas continues to be a major unsolved problem. Although mature fistulas survive longer than grafts, this advantage largely disappears when the two types of access are compared from the time of surgical creation [1-3]. Moreover, in the DAC multicenter randomized controlled trial, 61% of fistulas failed to mature sufficiently to be used for dialysis . Thus, methods of predicting fistula maturation outcome and preventing maturation failure are under intense investigation. The causes of maturation failure can be divided into 4 general categories (Fig. 1): 1. Surgical skill, expe-rience and patient selection; 2. Pre-existing vascular disease; 3. Upstream events; and 4. Downstream events. Upstream events are the mechanisms that initially cause injury to the endothelium (surgical trauma, hemodynamic shear stress, vessel wall injury caused by needle punctures, etc.) . Downstream events are the responses to endothelial injury (leukocyte adhesion, migration of smooth muscle cells from the media to the intimal layer, smooth muscle proliferation, etc.) . The figure emphasizes that although upstream and downstream events are important steps in maturation failure, pre-existing vascular disease should not be neglected as it sets the stage for what follows. This review will address the influence of pre-existing vascular disease on maturation.
The four categories that explain the causes of fistula maturation failure.
THE VASCULOPATHY OF ESRD
Atherosclerosis and arteriosclerosis are the major causes of cardiovascular disease in ESRD (Fig. 2), but arteriosclerosis probably accounts for the bulk of cardiovascular deaths [7-10]. Atherosclerosis is an intimal disease characterized by plaques and occlusive lesions, and is the accepted cause of most of the vascular diseases in the general population. In contrast, arteriosclerosis in ESRD is largely a disease of the medial layer characterized by increased collagen content, calcification, and both hypertrophy and hyperplasia of vascular smooth muscle cells [7, 9, 11-13]. These changes result in increased thickness and stiffness of the arterial wall. ESRD patients develop cardiovascular complications that far exceed what would be expected from traditional risk factors alone . Arteriosclerosis fills the gap and can be considered to be the vasculopathy of ESRD. Concomitant presence of diabetes mellitus can contribute to these abnormalities through accumulation of inelastic material in the arterial wall .
The two major causes of vascular disease in ESRD. Nitric Oxide deficiency may play an important role in fistula maturation failure.
The increased arterial stiffness of arteriosclerosis yields high systolic and pulse pressures [9, 10, 16]. These hemodynamic changes are caused by the loss of dampening function of arteries, which promotes an increase in pulse wave velocity. In a normal vascular circuit, arterial pulse waves are reflected back from the periphery and branch points, and these reflected waves ordinarily augment diastolic pressure and thereby enhance coronary perfusion. However, when pulse waves travel more quickly, reflected waves may return during systole, thereby augmenting systolic pressure and reducing diastolic pressure. Arteriosclerosis helps explain the enhanced structural heart disease in ESRD, which leads to complications such as congestive heart failure, arrhythmias, and sudden death [17-20].
There has been a growing realization that the vasculopathy of ESRD is not restricted to the artery. When Feinfeld et al. examined veins of hemodialysis patients that had not been used for creation of a vascular access, they found that the widths of the intimal and medial layers were increased . Moreover, neointimal hyperplasia and calcification have been documented in veins prior to access surgery [22-24]. Thus, the vasculopathy of ESRD appears to be general, and approaches to solve the problem of maturation failure may need to address both arteries and veins.
ROLE OF DILATATION IN FISTULA MATURATION
Inflammation, endothelial dysfunction, and nitric oxide deficiency are major causes of the arterial stiffness that contributes to fistula maturation failure [25-29]. Nitric oxide activates guanylate cyclase, which increases the level of cyclic guanosine monophosphate (cGMP). cGMP then induces vascular smooth muscle relaxation, which causes vessels to dilate. Thus, lack of nitric oxide impairs vessel dilatation, which may lead to maturation failure because dilatation of the anastomosed artery and vein is the key step in fistula maturation.
The stiff, thickened and calcified vessels of dialysis patients may not respond well to signals such as nitric oxide that promote dilatation. Inadequate dilatation and remodeling of a fistula may yield a vein with a luminal diameter that is too small for repeated cannulation by dialysis needles. Since the artery is generally narrower than the vein, the artery is the chief source of vascular resistance in a new fistula. Thus, arterial dilatation also appears to be a key step in maturation.
Fistula maturation begins with creation of the artery-vein anastomosis, which causes an increase in flow and shear stress. Increased shear stress then promotes release of nitric oxide, which ideally causes dilatation of the artery and vein so that shear stress returns toward pre-fistula levels [30, 31]. The increased pressure in the vein also promotes dilatation and remodeling (medial hypertrophy). Thus, adequate elasticity and nitric oxide are necessary for vessel dilatation during fistula maturation.
However, arteriosclerosis impairs the arterial elasticity that is necessary for dilatation [9, 12, 13, 16], and endothelial dysfunction with reduced nitric oxide production further impairs vasodilatation [25-29]. Thus, ESRD patients have poor nitric oxide-dependent flow mediated dilatation . Also, most failed fistulas develop stenosis at the artery-vein anastomosis or downstream in the outflow vein. Stenosis is believed to be caused by low or oscillatory shear stress and turbulent flow [33, 34], which may be enhanced in the absence of dilatation. It follows that increased arterial stiffness and reduced nitric oxide can be expected to play key roles in maturation failure.
Preoperative duplex ultrasound mapping of vessels has been used to establish minimal acceptable diameters when evaluating patients for fistula creation. The recommended minimal diameters have varied from study to study, but the most widely accepted values for the artery and vein are generally 2.0 and 2.5 mm, respectively . Unfortunately, the success of mapping has been mixed, and has done little to improve maturation rates [4, 36]. Nevertheless, smaller luminal diameters are a dilatation challenge that is generally best avoided.
Preoperative ultrasound measurement of vessel diameters has had limited benefit in improving maturation in part because diameter alone does not determine the suitability of a vessel. Rather, the key to suitability is the ability of the vessel to dilate in response to an increase in shear stress. A contributing factor is that ultrasound is observer dependent and may lack adequate reproducibility . Consequently, there has been growing interest in preoperative testing of vessel function (i.e. elasticity) in the hope that this will provide an adequate estimate of a vessel’s ability to dilate .
DEFINITIONS OF INDICES OF ELASTICITY (STIFFNESS)
The general properties of arteries vary depending upon their diameter, location, and content of elastin, collagen, and smooth muscle. We are concerned here with the smaller peripheral muscular arteries, such as the brachial and radial arteries. Definitions of stiffness are complex because the arterial wall is not homogeneous, and elastic properties vary depending on a number of factors, including the distending pressure and vessel diameter. Thus, a number of indices for measuring stiffness have been developed, and these can be a source of confusion. For example, compliance and distensibility may seem to be synonymous, but they are not so in the nomenclature of this field [39, 40]. Arterial compliance is defined as the change in diameter of an artery (∆D) divided by the increase in pressure (∆P): ∆D/∆P. On the other hand, arterial distensibility measures arterial compliance relative to vessel diameter: (∆D/D)/∆P. This distinction is important because different components of the vessel wall are recruited for stretching as the diameter increases, and this changes the measured compliance or distensibility.
In this review, we will use terms such as elasticity, stiffness, compliance, and distensibility interchangeably according to the terminology of authors, many of whom do not apply the formal definitions of indices. Excellent reviews are available that explain the indices and their physiology [39, 40].
TESTING VESSEL ELASTICITY
There is a growing literature on methods of measuring elasticity of arteries and veins, a number of which are listed in Table 1 [40, 41]. Although most of these methods have correlated with maturation outcome, studies have generally been limited by their small size and scope, and results among various researchers have not always been consistent. Thus, no definitive criteria for applying tests of elasticity have been established in this emerging field. Tests that are adopted for widespread clinical use will need to be easy to apply - a standard that many of these tests do not meet.
Methods of measuring vessel elasticity or distensibility that may help predict fistula maturation outcome.
|Application of tourniquet (diameter by duplex ultrasound)||[42-45]|
|Warm water immersion (diameter by duplex ultrasound)|||
|Finite element analysis combined with duplex ultrasound|||
|Lok Criteria (age, peripheral vascular disease, coronary artery disease, race)|||
|Aortic pulse wave velocity|||
|Cardio-ankle modification of pulse wave velocity|||
|High resolution ultrasound speckle-tracking algorithms||[38, 52]|
|Elastic modulus by duplex ultrasound|||
|Flow mediated dilatation of brachial artery|||
|Resistance index measured during fist relaxation after fist clenching||[36, 43, 45]|
|Small artery elasticity index by tonometer||[56-58]|
Application of a tourniquet to the proximal arm has been used to test the ability of a vein to dilate . In this method, proximal (downstream) pressure on the vein is incrementally increased by tightening the tourniquet and the increase in luminal diameter is measured by ultrasound at each step. The tourniquet method of measuring distensibility has correlated with maturation outcome [43-45]. An alternative method of promoting vein dilatation is by warm water immersion . Measurement of forearm venous distensibility by strain-gauge plethysmography has also correlated with maturation outcome . In a novel approach, finite element analysis has been combined with ultrasonography to measure vein compliance .
Lok et al. have developed criteria for estimating risk of maturation failure based upon clinical factors : age > 65 years old, presence of peripheral vascular disease or coronary artery disease, and black race. It seems likely that Lok’s criteria are a largely surrogates for arterial stiffness, which suggests that more specific measures of stiffness may be even more useful.
Aortic pulse wave velocity measurements have long been the gold standard in measuring arterial stiffness . This method is conceptually easy as it measures the difference in time of travel to two different points in the arterial system (e.g. carotid and femoral arteries). The difference in distance traveled divided by time is the pulse wave velocity. The cardio-ankle vascular index is a modification of pulse wave velocity that is intended to improve measurement of arterial stiffness by adjusting for the effect of blood pressure on velocity . The ongoing Hemodialysis Fistula Maturation Study may help establish the value of pulse wave velocity in predicting maturation outcome .
The feasibility of applying other measures of elasticity in ESRD has been explored. High resolution ultrasound speckle-tracking algorithms have been used to measure arterial compliance [38, 52]. Duplex ultrasound has been used to measure the elastic modulus of the brachial artery, which is inversely related to arterial elasticity . Finally, the digital volume pulse is a noninvasive method of assessing arterial stiffness that uses photoplethysmography to analyze the contour of the digital pulse . The effectiveness of these methods in predicting maturation outcome remains to be tested.
Studies that have tested the influence of flow-mediated dilatation on fistula outcomes have had some success. Flow mediated dilatation of the brachial artery has correlated with the increase in arterial and venous diameter at 3 months after fistula creation . In flow mediated dilatation, ischemia is induced with a tourniquet applied to the arm. Release of the tourniquet causes dilatation of arterioles, which increases brachial artery blood flow. The higher flow then yields an increase in shear stress, which induces nitric oxide release and brachial artery dilatation. It should be realized, however, that the method depends upon reactive vasodilatation induced by ischemia, and is therefore not strictly equivalent to measuring arterial stiffness or response to nitric oxide per se.
A similar approach uses fist relaxation after sustained fist clenching. This produces transient arteriole dilatation of the distal hand that is similar to the mechanism of flow-mediated dilatation. Malovrh found that resistance index and blood flow before and after fist clenching correlated with successful maturation , but resistive index did not in two other studies [36, 45].
ROLE OF SMALL ARTERY ELASTICITY INDEX
The HDI/PulseWave CR-2000 System (Hypertension Diagnostics, Inc., Eagan, MN) provides a measure of small artery and large artery elasticity index [56, 57]. The instrument uses a noninvasive tonometer to perform pulse contour analysis of radial artery waveforms, and easily yields a measurement in approximately 5 minutes. The only practical limitation is that the vascular system in the arm should not be altered by surgery or other major abnormalities.
We previously used this device to test the hypothesis that these measures of elasticity correlate with fistula maturation outcome . On the day of fistula surgery, 32 patients underwent preoperative measurement of arterial blood pressure, and small and large artery elasticity indexes. Fistulas were considered mature if they were used successfully in 3 consecutive treatments within 6 months of surgery. Six fistulas were excluded from analysis of maturation because dialysis did not begin within 6 months.
Six out of 26 remaining fistulas failed to mature, and all 6 developed stenosis at the arteriovenous anasto-mosis. Average small artery elasticity index was lower in failed than in matured fistulas (3.71 ± 0.29 (±SE) vs 2.25 ± 0.33 ml/mmHg x100, P = 0.02) (Fig. 3A), but there was no significant difference in large artery elasticity index. Both groups had low elasticity when compared with published control groups. For example, Prisant et al.  previously obtained an average small artery elasticity index of 7.0 ml/mmHg x100 in a normal control group.
2 Relationship between small artery elasticity index and outcome of fistula maturation. B. Probability of successful fistula maturation vs small artery elasticity index .
We used multivariable logistic regression analysis to analyze the risk of maturation failure . We found that lower small artery elasticity index (P = 0.008) (Fig. 3B and lower body mass index (P = 0.02) were independent predictors of maturation failure. Lower body mass index may have favored failure because it was associated with smaller vein diameter (R2= 0.158, P = 0.04). Another contributing factor may have been that leaner dialysis patients tend to have more cardiovascular disease, extracellular fluid excess and higher mortality .
HOW SHOULD ARTERIAL ELASTICITY BE MEASURED?
We have previously suggested that the Lok’s criteria  for predicting maturation failure are a clinical surrogate for arterial stiffness. A more direct clinical method of assessing arterial elasticity is provided by the standard blood pressure measurement. The high pulse wave velocity of stiff vessels causes reflected arterial waves to return during systole rather than during diastole. This results in a high pulse pressure and high systolic pressure with reduced diastolic pressure. Thus, we found that maturation failure correlated with higher pulse and systolic pressures (Fig. 4) . However, the two variables were not independent risk factors when small artery elasticity index and body mass index were included in a multivariable model. Nevertheless, this suggests that such blood pressure measurements should be considered when patients undergo preoperative access planning.
Relation between small artery elasticity index vs systolic blood pressure and pulse pressure .
The CR-2000 device that we used to measure elasticity requires little training and is easy to apply [56-58, 60]. The instrument measures arterial waveforms and uses a modified Windkessel model to analyze the pressure pulse contour. The method is based on analysis of peripheral wave reflections superimposed on the diastolic decay of the basic pressure waveform. Large artery elasticity index reflects changes in the structure and compliance of large arteries, such as the aorta. Small artery elasticity index reflects changes in elasticity of arterioles and the smallest arteries, and includes reflections from branch points in the circulation. Small artery elasticity index is a more sensitive measure of vascular disease than large artery elasticity , and may detect vascular changes before they become irreversible, whereas large artery elasticity index reflects changes that may already be irreversible. The higher sensitivity of small artery elasticity in detecting vascular disease may explain why it was a better predictor of maturation .
The role of the modified Windkessel model in assessing vascular health is controversial. Some have supported the model [56, 62-64], whereas others have argued that the model has significant shortcomings [39, 41, 65, 66]. For example, the Windkessel model assumes that a pulse is transmitted instantaneously throughout the arterial circuit, which is an oversimplification. Some have criticized the model as being overly influenced by local vessel characteristics in a limb, suggesting that it may not be a true assessment of overall vascular health . However, all models involve simplifications of reality that hopefully incorporate essential physiology so that they provide clinically valid analyses. In this case, evaluation of vessels for fistula creation is primarily a local assessment, so this property should be an advantage. In any case, we found that the method correlated with clinical markers of arterial stiffness (systolic blood pressure and pulse pressure) (Fig. 4), and most important of all, it correlated with fistula outcome .
HOW SHOULD LOW ELASTICITY BE TREATED?
If the vasculopathy of ESRD plays an important role in fistula maturation failure, then treatments that prevent or reverse vessel stiffness should be considered. For example, the metabolic bone disease of ESRD is associated with arterial stiffness [8, 67, 68]. There has been concern that treatment with calcium containing phosphorus binders may contribute to calcification of vessels. Takenaka et al. found that pulse wave velocity decreased in 15 hemodialysis patients when they were switched from calcium carbonate to sevelamer for phosphorus binding . Thus, it seems prudent to control calcium and phosphorus plasma levels, and avoid calcium containing phosphorus binders if feasible. Inhibitors of vascular calcification also have potential to be useful .
Blood pressure medications that improve arterial elasticity should be emphasized [40, 71, 72]. If nitric oxide deficiency and endothelial dysfunction are major contributors to the vasculopathy of ESRD, then it makes sense to directly address this problem (Fig. 2). For example, Sildenafil enhances the effect of nitric oxide by inhibiting phosphodiesterase-5, which degrades cGMP; persistent action of cGMP thereby promotes continued vascular smooth muscle relaxation. This effect explains why sildenafil lowers arterial blood pressure and improves measures of vascular health in systemic arteries. For example, sildenafil reduces pulse wave velocity in patients with hypertension or coronary artery disease [73, 74]. In a pilot study , we have found that one 50 mg dose of sildenafil increased small artery elasticity index and decreased pulse wave velocity. Moreover, patients with the lowest baseline elasticity had the largest increase after taking sildenafil. Other medications that improve endothelial function such as endothelin antagonists , and antioxidants such as N-acetylcysteine , may also be helpful. Blockade of the renin-angiotensin-aldosterone system is associated with improved arterial elasticity. For example, spironolactone is associated with a reduction in arterial stiffness in chronic kidney disease .
We can conclude that vessel elasticity (stiffness) does indeed affect fistula maturation. Poor elasticity is an important step in the cascade of events that leads to maturation failure (Fig. 1). Moreover, arteriosclerosis is not only a major impediment to fistula maturation, but is the common pathway that leads to the major cause of death in ESRD: cardiovascular disease. Since dilatation of both the artery and vein is necessary for fistula maturation, both vessels appear to be important in predicting fistula maturation and preventing maturation failure. However, it is not enough to establish a statistical relationship between a preoperative test and maturation outcome. Such tests must satisfy statistical criteria, such as high sensitivity and specificity, and provide adequate positive and negative predictive values - criteria that to date have rarely been addressed in this emerging field. Moreover, in order for a test to be widely adopted clinically, it should be fast and easy to apply - a criterion that many tests described herein may not meet. Finally, the uremic milieu has many interacting elements of abnormal physiology that together may make prevention and treatment of maturation failure particularly challenging. Thus, the benefit and optimum criteria for evaluating and treating vascular elasticity remain to be established.
CONFLICT OF INTEREST
The author confirms that this article content has no conflict of interest.